buy cheap generic cialis buy cheap viagra online buy cheap viagra buy cialis no prescription buy discount online viagra buy female viagra buy generic online viagra buy online prescription viagra buy online viagra securely buy online viagra where buy pfizer viagra buy viagra online uk buy viagra order canada no prescription viagra canada viagra for sale canada viagra

“The gift that kept on giving”? Sex workers speak for themselves Sudhir Venkatesh

Sudhir Venkatesh has already had more than his allotted 15 minutes, but his most recent appropriation of sex workers’ lives gives us—sex workers, people in the sex trade, and allies—a moment to reflect on unethical researchers who have not yet realized that they are as much under the microscope as we are. New media and new forms of organizing building on at least 40 years of struggle for rights, means that the studies “revealing” the “secret” lives people in the sex trade are read and critiqued by members of those very same communities. Gone are the days where sociologists can effectively pretend that they speak for “silenced” or “silent” groups of people. The people who were once described as “deviant”, the drug users, the prostitutes, the “queers”, all the people whose communities were once considered a “playground” to provide the “raw materials” for academic research—the “gift that kept on giving” according to Sudhir— are not and in fact have never been compliant and silent.

SWOP-NYC and SWANK—two organizations lead by sex workers and their allies in the NYC area—have significant questions about the “research” carried out by Sudhir Venkatesh. In January 2011 members of our organizations were shocked to read a piece by Venkatesh in Wired Magazine. Here he made many outlandish, salacious, and false claims about the experiences of sex workers in NYC including suggestions that sex workers “always” carry “extra panties” with them to sell to men as souvenirs and that escorts “keep working to pay for clothes and shoes” even though they are “beaten, twice a year on average”.

We wondered about veracity of Venkatesh “findings”—he said he had “followed” 270 sex worker subjects in NYC but none of our membership had ever been contacted by him nor knew of anyone who had been—so we carefully examined the investigations he said he had done with sex workers over a ten year period. We found that his “research history” simply did not add up. Claims in articles online, in the Journal of Contemporary Ethnography, and on the Freakonomics blog regarding the dates, locations and numbers of people in his research were wildly inconsistent. His conclusions, for example about large numbers sex workers advertising on Facebook, were easily shown by other researchers and commentators to be incorrect. Other conclusions such as the fiction that “there’s usually a 25% surcharge” to have sex without a condom not only bore no relationship to reality but also endangered sex workers and public health programs working with them.

 We were so concerned by what we uncovered that in October 2011 we wrote a letter to the Columbia IRB to the Columbia University Institutional Review Board (IRB) and to the Sociology Department asking for some clarity about Sudhir Venkatesh’s research. Specifically, we asked for the research project titles, dates of research, and IRB approval numbers for each of the years he claimed to have conducted research while at Columbia University. We also wished to make Columbia University’s IRB and the Sociology Department aware of that the research appeared to create additional harms and risks for sex workers in the New York area. Our action is an example of the degree to which communities of sex workers have organized and the degree to which we will question research that we find harmful. We are no longer a “gift that keeps on giving” for Venkatesh, we are a community that speaks for itself.

 But clearly we need to educate the media more about this issue. It is not so much our worry that respected publications such as The Guardian and Mother Jones have seemingly accepted that Venkatesh’s current book has some validity—though we certainly encourage these and other media outlets to be more diligent in terms of speaking to the communities supposedly “spoken” for by Venkatesh in the future—it is that Venkatesh’s whole body of work regarding sex work and other informal economies is bankrupt. And Venkatesh is simply an extreme example of an older form of sensationalist, inaccurate “research” which is becoming less and less relevant in the world today. People in the sex trade have done their own research—excellent examples are community based research by the Young Women’s Empowerment Project and the Alliance for Safe and Diverse DC—and new relationships based on mutual respect after some soul-searching about the impact of power differentials on “the researched” are now emerging all across the United States. This is the real story we wish would be covered in the media if journalists can wean themselves off from the tantalizing (yet completely fallacious) fantasy sold by people like Venkatesh.

2 comments ↓

#1 That Was the Week That Was (#338) | The Honest Courtesan on 09.20.13 at 2:02 am

[...] Educated Idiot SWOP-NYC and SWANK…have significant questions about the “research” carried out by Sudhir Venka……[and reported] in January 2011…in Wired Magazine…he made many outlandish, salacious, and [...]

#2 when your research population organizes against you, NYC sex worker edition | haba na haba on 10.15.13 at 2:55 am

[...] Venkatesh is a professor of sociology at Columbia University. The quote above is from a post on the The Sex Worker’s Outreach Project NYC (SWOP-NYC) blog. SWOP-NYC challenges claims made by Venkatesh about NYC sex workers in his published research, on [...]

You must log in to post a comment.

buy viagra meds online
generic form of viagra
buy cialis tadalafil
Buy cialis Omaha
buy viagra in england
viagra 10 generic
cheap drugs viagra cialas
buy cheap generic zyban
Buy cialis Houston
cheap gen viagra bi
Buy cialis Charlotte
buy viagra online at
buy levitra
cheap caverta
Buy cialis Atlanta
Buy levitra Washington
generic viagra viagrageneric
buy generic levitra online
online viagra testosterone
Buy viagra Louisville
buy cialis softtabs
buy cialis uk
buy somas
buy viagra in amsterdam
buy premarin
buy now cialis
buy cozaar
buy caverta
buy carisoprodol generic soma
buy panerai watches
generic viagra us licensed online pharmacy
Buy levitra El Paso
buy viagra in boston
buy generic singulair
buy generic lipitor online
buy glucophage
buy paxil
buy lopressor
Buy viagra Charlotte
generic viagra for sale
Buy viagra Phoenix
cheap viagra fast shipping
cheap evista generic order
buy locally viagra
Buy viagra Portland
Buy viagra El Paso
buy diflucan
buy cheap generic ultram
buy avandia
Buy cialis San Francisco
online viagra australia
cheap allegra online pharmacy
cheapest premarin
cheap canadian cialis online
Buy levitra Seattle
Buy cialis Buffalo
msi k7n2 delta 2
online viagra pharmacie miami florida
online viagra consultation
Buy levitra Phoenix
Buy cialis Las Vegas
buy viagra jacksonville
buy viagra new york
generic viagra cheap
buy viagra safeway pharmacy
generic viagra uk
buy generic viagra buy
ordering viagra without prescription
Buy viagra Memphis
cheapest xenical
cheap est xenical online
onlinenmru ultram
buy tamiflu
buy viagra orlando
buy cialis re
buy viagra or cilas
cheapest zocor
buy singulair
Buy cialis Seattle
Buy levitra Portland
Buy cialis Kansas City
cheap genric viagra online
buy viagra professional
cheapest viagra
buy generic xenical
buy viagra sale
cheap generic nolvadex order
buy cheap kamagra uk
Buy viagra Fresno
Buy levitra Louisville
buy generic cialis softtabs cheap
buy atarax
buy generic cialis softtabs online
Buy levitra Oxnard
cheapest pravachol
buy viagra viagra online
buy levitra now
Buy levitra Baltimore
buy claritin
buy viagra from britain
buy viagra in uk
buy viagra removethis
buy protonix
buy viagra now online
online perscriptions for viagra
Buy viagra Albuquerque
buy canada online zyban
buy viagra cialis online
generic india viagra
buy levitra online
online zyrtec
buy viagra from canada
purchasing viagra in venezuela
buy coumadin
Buy viagra Modesto
buy viagra now
online ordering viagra
buy nolvadex
buy nexium consultation
Buy viagra New Orleans
generic viagra rd
generic viagra caverta veega
buy viagra dallas
buy viagra san diego
buy cheap online xenical
Buy cialis Fort Worth
Buy cialis Riverside
Buy cialis Austin
buy cialis we
Buy cialis Rome
cheap allegra without prescription
cheapest paxil
buy viagra pill
buy propecia
Buy cialis Milwaukee
phizer viagra
buy kamagra canada
buy generic zocor
generic viagra quality
cheap generic viagra online
online viagra viagra
Buy levitra Las Vegas
purchasing viagra online
Buy cialis Phoenix
Buy cialis Pittsburgh
cheap cialis from shanghai
buy norvasc
buy viagra prescription
cheap discount india viagra
Buy viagra Fort Worth
buy generic ultram
buy generic viagra img
buy viagra from brazil
buy viagra fedex
buy celebrex
buy viagra soft
buy cheap imitrex online
buy viagra san jose
generic viagra trial pack
Buy viagra Indianapolis
buy viagra pill online
buy viagra using paypal
buy cialis
buy neurontin prescription
Buy cialis Memphis
buy generic viagra usa
online viagra no generic
Buy levitra New Orleans
buy levitra cheap
buy lexapro
Buy cialis Baltimore
Buy cialis Columbus
generic viagra cialis
buy generic viagra pharmacy online
buy generic nexium online
online viagra canada
buy propecia for less
cheap cialis pharmacy online
buy nexium
generic viagra work
Buy levitra Charlotte
cheap viagra cialis india
Buy levitra Nashville
buy cheap diflucan online
Buy viagra Tulsa
buy levitra us
cheap atarax no prescription
buy viagra no prescription
buy depakote
buy viagra with discount
buy viagra for less
Buy levitra Atlanta
buy viagra securely online
buy viagra online pharmacy
cheap generic propecia finasteride
generic viagra caverta veega generic viagra
Buy levitra Denver
buy amaryl
Buy viagra Mesa
Buy cialis Oxnard
cheapest soma
Buy levitra Milwaukee
buy viagra low cost
buy viagra usa
buy imitrex
buy canada diovan hydrochloride
Buy cialis Louisville
buy buy prilosec online
Buy viagra Tacoma
buy lasix
Buy cialis Indianapolis
online prescription prilosec viagra
buy cipro
generic indian viagra
cheap cialis for you
Buy levitra Omaha
Buy levitra Memphis
cheap generic india viagra
buy viagra in london
generic viagra us pharmacy
online viagra sale
buy viagra with paypal
generic viagra purchase
buy n viagra
buy viagra pills
generic viagra drugstore india
online prescription viagra
Buy cialis Richmond
Buy cialis Long Beach
buy viagra inte
ddr2 memory
cheapest zantac
buy viagra online cheap
buy neurontin online
buy viagra line
online parm viagra
generic viagra pricing
buy levitra onlines
Buy levitra Pittsburgh
cheap celebrex
generic viagra viagra
buy discount buspar
purchasing viagra online for cheap
online purchase viagra viagra
Buy levitra Riverside
online sales viagra
buy line propecia
Buy cialis San Antonio
buy viagra online cheapest
buy viagra uk online
buy cialis pill
buy nolvadex drug
Buy levitra Buffalo
buy line viagra
buy zithromax
buy nolvadex liquid
generic viagra discount
Buy levitra Oakland
Buy levitra Newark
german viagra substitutes
Buy cialis Oakland
buy generic viagra
generic viagra canada
Buy viagra Long Beach
buy generic tamiflu
Buy viagra Seattle
buy viagra for women
buy viagra or levitra
buy replica watches
buy viagra onli ne
buspar online
generic viagra tab
buy viagra in malaysia
free christmas ringtones
online viagra prescription canada
online viagra order
Buy levitra Philadelphia
buy viagra in spain
buy viagra in vancouver
buy viagra per pill
buy viagra online canadian
Buy levitra Mesa
buy rolex watch replica
buy viagra iframe src
buy viagra phuket
online prescription for viagra
buy viagra internet
cheap claritin d 12hr
online viagra sales
discount buspar
buy isoptin
online viagra levitra cialis
buy viagra online uk
buy viagra soft online
viagra 100 50 25
buy viagra online order
buy cheap online propecia
buy neurontin
buy herbal viagra
buy montblanc
generic viagra drugs brand order pill
buy viagra discrete england
generic viagra usa
buy zyrtec
generic viagra wholesale
Buy viagra Tucson
buy multi vitamins
Buy viagra Philadelphia
buy cheap generic viagra
cheap altace no prescription
online uk viagra sales
philippines viagra
ordering viagra online
generic viagra wholesale 100mg
buy viagra onlines
buy corum watches
buy cheap online soma
buy generic viagra online
buy generic levitra cheap
buy norvasc 10mg
buy linecom soma
Buy cialis Detroit
Buy levitra Columbus
buy generic cialis uk
generic viagra propecia
buy cialis today
buy viagra online online
buy viagra ebay
buy viagra in canada
buy viagra
buy lasix fast
buy cheap generic cialis
buy cheap diflucan generic
Buy viagra Riverside
buy generic tramadol no prescription
buy cialis viagra
buy generic propecia online
cheap generic cialis pills
Buy viagra Las Vegas
online pharmacy viagra no prescription
cheapest zithromax
buy viagra london
cheap buspar
generic viagra cheap no prescription
cheap generic cialis tadalafil
buy viagra cleveland
generic viagra cheapest
Buy cialis Arlington
buy viagra cheap prices
buy xenical
buy nexium cheap
buy generic online prilosec
buy plavix
Buy levitra Rome
buy norvasc 5mg
buy generic cialis softtabs
buy viagra cheap online
buy viagra com
generic in uk viagra
cheap altace
generic viagra year
online viagra prescriptions
cheap cialis no prescription
online viagra store
online viagra prescription
Buy levitra Tacoma
buy cheap buspar
Buy viagra Baltimore
buy viagra vermont
buy cialis soft
generic viagra fast delivery
buy viagra at safeway
cheapest silagra
buy cheap evista generic
buy ultram
buy swiss watch
Buy viagra Kansas City
cheapest singulair
bye viagra
buy viagra online purchase
generic viagra tadalafil
online shop viagra
buy viagra florida
Buy cialis Mesa
buy viagra pharmacy online
generic viagra doxycycline
buy viagra by pill
buy viagra texas
buy cheap evista online
online viagra pills
Buy levitra Fresno
generic viagra pills
buy retin-a
generic viagra when
cheap cialis
buy levitra vardenafil
cheap generic viagra deals
generic in usa viagra
Buy levitra San Antonio
generic viagra cialis levitra buy cheap